Subscribe

Resources

« MySpace: $1B of Revenue in 2007 UPDATED | Main | Time to Update Those Facebook Revenue Estimates »

July 27, 2007

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451656f69e200e39330ae198834

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference The (Big) Problem For Hakia, Powerset, Mahalo, and Other Google-Killers:

Comments

pwb

I cannot stand natural language search myself but I've tried to keep an open mind that perhaps others like it.

You Mon Tsang

Many ships have been wrecked by the siren call of natural language processing. It sounds so good, feels so right, but never seems to be better than the simpler alternatives.

Christian

Henry, couldn't agree more with your assessment. Over the last 2 weeks I was pitched 2 new search engines as well - i didn't even try them out because to me search in the google way is simply not broken. I'm used to the way it works, it produces great results and it's already in my browser. So unless Google's result quality deteriorates badly - no need for yet another new search engine.

ProfitTheme

Just what we need, another search engine LOL.

Still Inside

Natural language processing has always failed (recall that Ask got its start with NLP and subsequently the Jeeves guy went the way of rodney allen rippy).

The problem is pretty simple: most people can figure out that typing "can you tell me what the weather in like in Las Vegas right now?" and "vegas weather" are the same thing to a search engine, but the latter is a lot less typing.

Wiki* does not seem to have anything we haven't seen many times already and neither do any of the others. It's certainly possible somebody can invent a new paradigm for Search, but it hasn't been done yet. Google's genius was to actually focus on Search when everybody else gave it up for dead. Trying that trick again is like trying to hijack an airplane with a box cutter.

SI

Still Inside

Ok, I normally don't double-post, but I had to try out Hakia just for fun. Fun indeed. You can always crush these little engines by looking for something slightly obscure. So I tried the following:

"what stocks went up today?"

Hilarious.

(The question is, do they read this blog and will they "fix" that query and will they still think their idea is going to scale to billions of queries)?

SI

Samir Shah

I, for one, find Hakia refreshing.

Henry's tone and tone of some others in the comments sounds too much like fear and/or mockery of new technology. The kind that used to say "Command line works for me fabulously, I do not need GUI". One needs Natural Language Query as much as you needs GUI (away from command line) and some of the questions that Henry asked himself prove the point.

NitinK

Great post! Although it's surprising to find almost no dissent among the comments to a blog post that takes such a clear position (other than Samir Shah's comment).

I have to disagree with you, at several levels:
(Forgive me, I'm using my own older posts to provide more detail for my points)

1. I think it's easy to confuse the approaches used by Hakia and Powerset, since both are clubbed into the area of "Semantic processing". But there's a distinct difference: although Hakia, as you describe, uses semantic parsing to analyze the query, Powerset is applying linguistic algorithms to make sense of the underlying content in their index. This could create a huge bump in the relevance of search results, compared to Google, which uses the venerable PageRank and proximity of text phrases to rank results.
More details on Powerset's approach here: Powerset is Not a Google-killer!

2. You say that "current search does not suck". Oh, yes, it does! Not in ways that are obvious, until you see the possibilities, just as the designers of the ever-popular DC-3 airplane (which revolutionized air travel in its time) could not have imagined how jet aircraft could make propeller-driven airplanes obsolete.
Here's a list of Search Innovations outside Google, on the Read/WriteWeb.

3. Finally, Google has also started down the path of "special-casing" search results (an almost Mahalo-like approach, although it's more complex for Google since tweaking the search algorithm can have unintended consequences on other queries) - an interesting development, albeit troubling:
The Hidden Dangers of Special Casing Google Search Results

- Nitin


replica watches

replica-watches-cn.com was established in 2003,an onlineshop of a replica watches manufacturer for exporting the international market. Since begining we dedicated to offer our customers with the best replica watches and the most friendly service. Yes, we have earned the trust.we now own many fixed customers all over the world, we have been the friends.They often visit our site even not for buying the watch, they email us for greeting or drop some words. We sincerely thanks for their long-term supports.Over the past 5 years, we have grown to be a large fake watches center by co-operating with other 10 large replica manufactures.Now more than 50 famous brands are available for every appetite buyer,such as Rolex, Omega, Longines,Patek Philippe,LOUIS VUITTON, Piaget, IWC, Breitling, TagHeuer, Cartier, VACHERON CONSTANTIN, Panerai, Bvlgari, Chanel, Chopard, Gucci and so on... We guarantee the lowest prices and the toppest replicas you'll find here.

Account Deleted

Bu web sitesinde sizler icin hazirlanmis olan sexfilmiseyret videolari bulunmaktadir.İzleyeceginiz videolar ozenle secilmis pornolardır. Youjizz kalitesindeki bircok videoyu bunyesinde barindirmaktadir. Kuresellesen dunya uzerinde degismeyen sitelerin ve kalitenin oncusu olan sitelerimiz sizlere daha iyi hizmet verebilmek icin 24 saat boyunca kesintisiz calismaktadir. Keyifli seyirler dileriz.

Account Deleted

en iyi tatil koyleri

Account Deleted

En iyi chat sitesi

The comments to this entry are closed.

Sponsors